Skip to content

arch/opt-bandwidth-as-bandwidth

Rule opt-bandwidth-as-bandwidth
Pack arch
Severity warning
Fix unsafe, with xpd check --fix --unsafe-fixes
Library versions arch 9.0 and later

Since arch 9.0, these estimators use opt_bandwidth minus 1 as their bandwidth, so passing opt_bandwidth back gives another estimate. Pass the estimator's bandwidth instead.

first = Bartlett(returns)
again = Bartlett(returns, bandwidth=first.opt_bandwidth)
again = Bartlett(returns, bandwidth=first.bandwidth)

The rule reports bandwidth= set to the opt_bandwidth of an estimator, on Bartlett, Gallant, NeweyWest, Parzen, ParzenCauchy, ParzenGeometric, ParzenRiesz, TukeyHamming, TukeyHanning and TukeyParzen.

xpd check --fix --unsafe-fixes applies the fixes of this rule. Check the result, because an unsafe fix can change what the code does.

The unsafe fix writes bandwidth=est.bandwidth for bandwidth=est.opt_bandwidth. The fixed call repeats the first estimate, so the number changes, 0.5158 to 0.5245 in the Bartlett example.

A kernel covariance estimator reports the bandwidth it used as bandwidth and the optimal bandwidth of Newey and West as opt_bandwidth. Before arch 9.0 the two were one number. Since 9.0 a kernel that is 0 beyond a finite lag uses opt_bandwidth minus 1, and the release notes say that Bartlett(x, bandwidth=est.opt_bandwidth) is not the same as Bartlett(x).

Estimator on 1,500 S&P 500 returns bandwidth opt_bandwidth Long run variance With bandwidth=opt_bandwidth
Bartlett, arch 9.0.0 10.943 11.943 0.52445 0.51582
Parzen, arch 9.0.0 20.467 21.467 0.48023 0.47335
QuadraticSpectral, arch 9.0.0 7.658 7.658 0.55401 0.55401
Bartlett, arch 8.0.0 19.221 19.221 0.45172 0.45172

A script built every estimator class of arch.covariance.kernel on 9.0.0 and compared the two attributes. The two attributes differ for the ten classes the rule names, and the rule leaves alone Andrews, QuadraticSpectral and ZeroLag, where they are equal. The document carries since: "9.0", and neither set of code had a report. The automatic bandwidth itself also changed in 9.0, from 19.221 to 10.943 for Bartlett, so an estimate without bandwidth differs between the two releases.

xpd prints this message with the issue. A name that starts with $ stands for code from your file.

Since arch 9.0 $K uses opt_bandwidth minus 1 as its bandwidth, so passing opt_bandwidth back gives another estimate. Bartlett gave a long run variance of 0.5245 on its own and 0.5158 with bandwidth=opt_bandwidth. Write bandwidth=$E.bandwidth to repeat the estimate.

Browse the other rules of the arch pack.